Topic 2: Open Learning – Sharing and Openness - Reflections by Chamara
Topic 2: Open Learning – Sharing and Openness
This was also an eye-opening week for me.
Stepped on to a topic which I my self has used while I was doing my PhD
studies, but never thought about it too much. After listening to the Ted talk by David
Wiley and reading through the article by Maha Bali et al. I was
able to broaden up my view that I had on open learning. For me, open learning
is getting access to education irrespective of wealth, gender, religion, citizenship etc. But at the end of the 2
weeks working on this, I was able to see that open learning is not only about
getting free access to educational resources at any time from anywhere in the
world. It also about openness in the pedagogical aspect of it. After reading
the blog post on the topic of What is Open Pedagogy? by
David Wiley, I realized that most of my educational efforts were on
creating Disposable Assignments. This was eye-opening for me. I am
sure that I try my best to avoid these type of assignments in my courses and
rather engage actively students to create the course material and tutorials.
This way the teaching will also be more learner-centric.
However, some questions started to puzzle me during this
topic. There is nothing called a "FREE" lunch. In an ideal
world, we could achieve the true definition of open learning. However, we are
living not in an ideal world. One of the highlighted part of openness in open
learning was getting access to education without any COST. At a first look,
this seems to be OK since we already have platforms like Edex,
Coursera that to a certain degree provide access to education
without any cost. But there is a hidden cost to it. I got to know that to
university to join these platforms, they have to pay a considerable amount of
money. Also, time money and recourses have to be spent on creating and
maintaining course on these platforms. Even to maintain the website with
all the content, someone has to pay a fee. So even though from the
learners perspective it's free, someone is paying the cost for it elsewhere.
Countries like Sweden and Finland have free education at least the
citizens of those countries can get access to. But the cost to make it free is
covered by the tax money each person pays. But there is a good side to it also.
If everyone in the country could get access to education without any cost, it
is highly likely that in the end, it benefits society as a whole. But
still quality has to maintain in education, otherwise, it will not add value to
society as expected.
Another thing is done taking a free course in a platform like Edex,
Coursera satisfy the objective and outcomes when you do the similar course
at a University. If yes, and imagine that all the courses that are in a
certain degree program are available in Coursera. Then if a person
completes all the course in Coursera, he or she is at the same level as
the student completing a degree at a university (on-campus or distance).
So then why still the certificate that we get from a university is more
recognized than the certificate than the course completing certificates that
one gets from Coursera?. One thing that should be mentioned here that most
of the free educational resources available online are mainly
targeting covering the theoretical aspect of a subject. When it comes to
education in medical and engineering, it is hard to convert a
practical experimental part of the course to an online version. I believe
that being able to access the information freely does not mean that you have learned
the subject.
My final thought is that one could still use
concepts from open learning/pedagogy even in a paid course. But then it will
not fit the current definition of openness in open learning!.
Hi Chamara, thank you for your interesting thoughts on free / open education. I agree with you that there are hidden costs to every 'free' course on the web. And I also agree with you that a Coursera course is never to be directly comparable to a semester on a Campus, even if you work (partially) online. There are no peers on Coursera, only recorded lectures, and professors who had been filmed. It might be great to watch those videos, yes, it's a welcome alternative to textbooks. But thats not really the thing, is it?
ReplyDeleteBut there's also a question what they get in return? I think they get data. Tons of data to evaluate. The magic word is Learning Analytics (LA). Maybe this is the currency we are paying with. I think there are ups and downs of LA and we definitely should discuss that in the future.